Spanky Oliver's Information

Walking into Spanky Oliver's on NY-31 in Lyons immediately gives you that welcoming small-town diner vibe, where the staff knows your name and the smell of fresh coffee mingles with sizzling breakfast favorites. The menu here is refreshingly diverse for a place of its size, offering everything from hearty omelets loaded with veggies and cheese to tender, juicy burgers that have clearly been crafted with care. On any given morning, you’ll see locals lingering over their pancakes, savoring the fluffy texture and generous portion sizes, while the aroma of bacon and sausage fills the air, making it hard to resist ordering one of each. The lunch options are just as satisfying, with sandwiches, wraps, and daily specials that rotate enough to keep regulars curious and returning. The service feels genuinely attentive without being intrusive; servers are quick with suggestions and always ready with a smile, creating a friendly atmosphere that makes you feel part of the community. The décor is casual yet charming, with comfortable seating that encourages lingering over a slow cup of coffee or a leisurely lunch. Patrons often comment on the consistency of the dishes, noting that whether it’s a classic club sandwich or the house-special burger, the flavors are reliably bold and satisfying. Even the sides get attention here-crispy fries, fresh-cut salads, and homemade soups round out meals perfectly. It’s the kind of spot where kids’ meals are handled thoughtfully and adult diners can indulge in generous portions without the rushed feeling of larger chains. Reviews frequently highlight how the location, right on NY-31, makes it an easy stop whether you’re passing through Lyons or making it a regular weekend treat. There’s a sense that the kitchen takes pride in quality, not just quantity, and that care translates into every bite, from breakfast to dinner. Overall, Spanky Oliver's manages to balance comfort, flavor, and hometown charm in a way that leaves a lasting impression, making it more than just a meal but a genuinely enjoyable dining experience.

What People's Say About Place

Great ice cream shop! So many choices! My new favorite thing is the orange/ vanilla twist! It's like the best 50-50 bar I've ever had! Just moved to Lyons, so happy to have Spanky Oliver's close by!!

Very fun little spot for insanely good ice cream. There are so many flavors and varieties to what you can get here that it was a little stunning to someone indecisive like me so definitely take a look at their menu before you stop by. Also the portions were pretty dang big and definitely worth the money spent plus very delicious!! I would highly, highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good, fair priced treat.

Perry's ice cream, along with several flavors of soft ice cream and sherbert, Flavor Burts. Pleasant service, clean outdoor tables. No inside service. Cash only.

4 stars ONLY because the location is not exactly in the best spot BUT it works... and the Ice Cream is pretty good. Lots of parking, tho not anywhere really to sit and enjoy. Assuming most sit on thier cars or in them. Friendly for 1st time experience, traffic makes it overwhelming a bit. Very doable tho.

Spanky Oliver's is a nice place to visit for some delicious ice cream. Located in downtown Lyons, NY, this is a unique spot to hang out and chill with some Perry's ice cream. There's plenty of outdoor seating or you can take it to go. I'd recommend the extreme flurries as they're loaded with your favorite choices of candy and they're a bit bigger than the normal flurries. I was surprised a bit at how many choices of dessert options there were to choose from and the prices are very affordable and will make you want to come back again when you pass through. I appreciated the service my wife and son and I received from the man working behind the counter. He was very kind and patient and made our experience more enjoyable. I'd recommend Spanky Oliver's to anybody because they'll spank your taste buds and leave you really satisfied

This is the best and least expensive ice cream place in the area. They have a wide variety of selections. Their loaded shakes are amazing. Their soft ice cream tastes very close to frozen custard. Very creamy. The owner is a great guy. They have many flavors of flavorburst. I would highly recommend this place for great ice cream.

The ice cream menu is huge and a little overwhelming. The staff was great! My boyfriend had a banana split that weighed about 5 lbs, and he loved it. They have soft serve and regular ice cream.

I hope this place never closes! It's decently priced and has friendly staff. Worth every cent!